Connecting Design and Experience: Tracing Uncertainty Through Classroom Science Investigations
Uncertainty has drawn substantial attention because of its potential to support conceptual progress and meaningful science work in science classrooms. Uncertainty has been conceptualized in a variety of ways: as central to scientific activity, as a design principle for science learning environments, and as an experience that supports individual and collective sensemaking. We argue that realizing uncertainty as a resource in learning environments requires working across multiple conceptions of uncertainty, specifically connecting
uncertainty as designed for
and
uncertainty as experienced in the learning environment
. We use an elementary school landforms investigation to apply design conjectures and develop an analytic method for following uncertainty from design through collective classroom engagement. We explore whether and how uncertainty was realized, made public, and taken up in classroom conversations. We highlight key findings that have continued to guide our work designing for productive uncertainty in classroom science. These include the interconnected nature of uncertainties in various parts of student investigations, the supportive role of consequential differences in helping students make uncertainty public, and teacher practices that impact how students make public and work with uncertainty.
No keywords indexed for this article. Browse by subject →
Ying‐Chih Chen, Michelle Jordan, Jongchan Park et al.
Ying‐Chih Chen, Ratrapee Techawitthayachinda
Randi A. Engle, Faith R. Conant
Michelle E. Jordan, Reuben R. McDaniel
Susan A. Kirch
Susan A. Kirch, Christina A. Siry
Eve Manz, Richard Lehrer, Leona Schauble
Eve Manz, Enrique Suárez
Kathleen E. Metz
Showing 50 of 77 references
- Published
- Sep 12, 2025
- Vol/Issue
- 110(2)
- Pages
- 557-579
- License
- View
You May Also Like
George J. Posner, Kenneth A. Strike · 1982
2,955 citations
Avi Hofstein, Vincent N. Lunetta · 2003
1,464 citations
Clark A. Chinn, Betina A. Malhotra · 2002
850 citations
Stephen P. Norris, Linda M. Phillips · 2003
827 citations
Adam V. Maltese, Robert H. Tai · 2011
679 citations