journal article
Open Access
Jan 01, 2024
Confucian Familialism and the Crisis of Care
Abstract
AbstractThis paper critically examines Confucian proposals for social welfare espoused by contemporary Confucian moral and political theorists, who promote a familialist, residual welfare state in which welfare provision should be the family's primary responsibility and public assistance be a last resort only available to the poor without family support. By investigating the situation in South Korea, a country whose welfare system bears a striking resemblance to the Confucian ideal, I argue that the Confucian scheme is inherently flawed. It considers poverty to be a personal failure, idealizes the family as a single unity of common interest free from power hierarchies, and lacks knowledge about social reproduction. Their proposal in actuality humiliates and excludes disadvantaged and marginalized people from social protection, abdicates the state's responsibility for the well-being of citizens, and colludes with capitalism in free riding on women's unpaid labor.
Topics
No keywords indexed for this article. Browse by subject →
References
72
[1]
Park, Hyun-jeong . 2019. In-cheon il-ga-jog bu-yang-ui-mu-ja gi-jun tas-e saeng-gye-geub-yeo sin-cheong-jo-cha mos-hae [Incheon family unable to claim benefits due to family support obligation]. Hankyoreh, November 22. https://www.hani.co.kr/arti/society/society_general/918161.html.
[4]
Jo (2014)
[6]
National Health Insurance Corporation. 2018. 2017nyeon no-in-jang-gi-yo-yang-bo-heom tong-gye-yeon-bo [Long-Term Care Insurance statistical yearbook, 2017]. National Health Insurance Cooperation. https://www.nhis.or.kr/nhis/together/wbhaec07200m01.do?mode=download&articleNo=126935&attachNo=49614
[7]
Korea, Statistics . 2020b. 2020nyeon o-wol gyeong-je-hwal-dong-in-gu-jo-sa go-lyeong-cheung bu-ga-jo-sa [Additional economically active population survey for older workers, May 2020].
[8]
Kim, Yoon-yeong . 2014. Song-pa se mo-nyeo-ui jug-eum, ga-nan-han i-e-ge kal gyeo-nun jeong-bu [Gov't responsible for death of Songpa family]. Pressian, March 3. https://www.pressian.com/pages/articles/115018?no=115018.
[9]
Chang, Woo-ri . 2020. Bang-bae-dong mo-ja bi-geug-e … bu-yang-ui-mu-ja gi-jun i-jen pye-ji-hae-ya [Bangbae family tragedy, no more famiy support obligation]. Yonhap News, December 16. https://www.yna.co.kr/view/AKR20201215162700004.
[11]
Kim, Eun-Ji , Hyo-Jean Song, Ho-Jung Bae , Bo-Young Sun, Jin-Hee Choi , and Hwang, Jeong-Mi . 2019. Jeo-chul-san dae-eung-jeong-chaeg pae-leo-da-im jeon-hwan-yeon-gu (1) [Paradigm shift in policy responses to low birthrates (I)]. Korean Women's Development Institute.
[12]
Korea, Statistics . 2020a. 2020 go-lyeong-ja-tong-gye [2020 older people statistics].
[13]
Lee, Kwi-won . 2014. Song-pa se-mo-nyeo-beob bon-hoe-ui tong-gwa, bog-ji-sa-gag an-jeon-mang gang-hwa [Songpa Mother and Daughters Law passed, strengthening social safety net]. Yonhap News, December 9. https://www.yna.co.kr/view/AKR20141209161600001.
[15]
Oh, Soojin . 2014. Jeong-bu, bog-ji-sa-gag-ji-dae il-je-jo-sa sil-si [Gov't launches emergency monitoring of low-income households in welfare blind spot]. Yonhap News, March 3. https://www.yna.co.kr/view/AKR20140303125151017.
[17]
Hahm (2003)
[18]
Federici (1975)
[19]
Gender and Social Reproduction: Historical Perspectives
Barbara Laslett, Johanna Brenner
Annual Review of Sociology
10.1146/annurev.so.15.080189.002121
[20]
Li (2014)
[22]
Hah, Sung-hee , and Kim, Jae-hee . 2019. Mae-dal son-e jwin geon i-sib-o-man-won-ppun … tto deu-leo-nan wol-se-bang mo-nyeo-ui bi-geug [Monthly income 250 thousand won, another tragedy of mother and dauther]. Donga Ilbo, January 22. https://www.donga.com/news/Society/article/all/20190122/93801155/1.
[23]
Hah, Min-ji . 2020. Sa-lam jug-eo-do an-ba-kkwi-neun je-do, bu-yang-ui-mu-ja gi-jun [Family support obligation rules never change even if people die]. BeMinor, December 31. https://www.beminor.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=20528.
[24]
Duncan (2000)
[25]
Ku "Decomposition analyses of the trend in poverty among older adults: The case of South Korea" Journals of Gerontology: Series B (2020)
[26]
Bahk, Eun-ji . 2019. Gov't to strengthen social security net to cover blind spot. Korea Times, September 5. https://www.koreatimes.co.kr/www/nation/2019/09/119_275180.html.
[27]
Tao "Dignity in long-term care for older persons: A Confucian perspective" Journal of Medicine and Philosophy: A Forum for Bioethics and Philosophy of Medicine (2007) 10.1080/03605310701626307
[28]
Hahm "Law, culture, and the politics of confucianism" Columbia Journal of Asian Law (2003)
[30]
McCurry, Justin . 2021. South Korea's population falls for first time in its history. Guardian, January 4. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/jan/04/south-korea-population-falls-for-first-time-in-history.
[31]
Pearson "Filial support laws in the modern era: Domestic and international comparison of enforcement practices for laws requiring adult children to support indigent parents" Elder Law Journal (2013)
[32]
Park, Sung-min . 2014. Bag-dae-tong-lyeong se-mo-nyeo ja-sal ma-eum-a-pa [President Park “heartbroken” over sucide of mother and two daughters]. Yonhap News, March 4. https://www.yna.co.kr/view/AKR20140304092853001.
[33]
Korea, Statistics . 2020c. The non-regular employment rate (in Korean). K-Indicator. 2020. https://www.index.go.kr/unify/idx-info.do?idxCd=4214&clasCd=7.
[34]
Yeo, Eugene . 2017. Bu-yang-ui-mu-ja gi-jun pye-ji-e tta-leun jeong-chaeg-gwa-je yeon-gu [A study on the policy implications of the abolition of the family support obligation rules]. Seoul: Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs. http://repository.kihasa.re.kr/handle/201002/29828.
[35]
OECD. 2021b. Gender wage gap. 2021. https://data.oecd.org/earnwage/gender-wage-gap.htm.
[36]
Folbre (2001)
[37]
(2018)
[38]
Seok, Jae-eun, Yongha Kim, Hae-yeon Kim, Hye-jin Noh, Hee-joon Shin, Eun-jin Chang, and Insu Hong. 2018. Sa-hoe-bo-jang 2040 jen-deo-pyeong-deung jeong-chaeg-mog-pyo ji-pyo gae-bal yeon-gu [2040 Gender impact assessment of social security policy for gender equality]. Ministry of Gender Equality and Family.
[39]
Chan (2014)
[40]
Won, Byeong-il . 2017. Saeng-hwal-sog hyo no-in-jang-gi-yo-yang-bo-heom-i ham-kke-hab-ni-da [Filial piety in daily life, LTCI with you]. Kyongin Ilbo. http://www.kyeongin.com/main/view.php?key=20170516010005057.
[41]
Lee, Seung-ho . 2014. 3 women found dead; suicide likely. Korea Joongang Daily, February 28. https://koreajoongangdaily.joins.com/news/article/article.aspx?aid=2985671.
[42]
Angle (2019)
[43]
Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs. 2017. 2017nyeon-do no-in-sil-tae-jo-sa [2017 analysis of the survey of living conditions and welfare needs of Korean older persons]. Sejong: Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs.
[44]
Rosenlee (2014)
[47]
Lee, Do-yeon . 2020. Sam-sib-dae nam-seong-eun gyeol-hon, yeo-seong-eun bi-hon seon-ho [Men and women in 30s want marriage and non-marriage respectively]. Yonhap News, September 24. https://www.yna.co.kr/view/AKR20200924129400530.
[48]
Hahm (2003)
[49]
Tan (2004)
[50]
Lee, Chang Gon . 2016. Na-hol-lo no-in, ja-nyeo dong-geo no-in-bo-da 2.8 bae ga-nan-ha-da [Elderly living alone 2.8 times poorer than elderly living with children]. Hankyoreh, June 21. http://www.hani.co.kr/arti/society/society_general/749077.html.
Showing 50 of 72 references
Metrics
4
Citations
72
References
Details
- Published
- Jan 01, 2024
- Vol/Issue
- 39(3)
- Pages
- 597-615
- License
- View
Cite This Article
Subin Lee (2024). Confucian Familialism and the Crisis of Care. Hypatia, 39(3), 597-615. https://doi.org/10.1017/hyp.2024.50
Related
You May Also Like
Evil Deceivers and Make-Believers: On Transphobic Violence and the Politics of Illusion
Talia Mae Bettcher · 2007
284 citations