Can Parental Love and Harm Coexist? The Perceptions of Child Protective Social Workers in Israel

Ayelet Guy Menashe; Bella Klebanov; Carmit Katz

doi:10.1111/cfs.70023

journal article Open Access Jul 28, 2025

Can Parental Love and Harm Coexist? The Perceptions of Child Protective Social Workers in Israel

Ayelet Guy Menashe Bella Klebanov

Carmit Katz

Child & Family Social Work Vol. 31 No. 2 pp. 988-998 · Wiley

View at Publisher Save 10.1111/cfs.70023

Abstract

ABSTRACT
Despite the undeniable significance of love in parent–child relationships, there is a gap in empirical research on this topic. Love's mythological, abstract and subjective nature complicates its academic investigation, often overshadowed by the presumption of its universal presence. The current study aimed to explore the intricate nature of parental love through the lens of child protection social workers (CPSWs) working with children at risk due to harm, abuse, neglect or self‐risk behaviours up to the age of 18. Utilizing qualitative methods, 20 in‐depth interviews were conducted. Two themes were identified: the unchallenged belief in parental love and its therapeutic potential within the parent–child nexus. This study illuminates the roles of parental love in scenarios of child abuse and neglect from the perspective of CPSWs. The findings emphasize that viewing love as a given shields CPSWs from confronting the possibility that a parent may not love their child. This perception facilitates their work with parents who have harmed their children, enabling them to engage these parents as agents of change. The research advocates for engaging in open and authentic dialogues with parents within the framework of child abuse and maltreatment. This perspective not only challenges prevailing stereotypes but also highlights the necessity of personalized support and understanding in addressing the complexities surrounding parenting and child welfare.

Topics

No keywords indexed for this article. Browse by subject →

References

34

[1]

10.1017/s0140525x00075828

[2]

Ben Shlomo S. "Lishmor al Habayit: Tioria Vepractika Shel Yetzirat Brit Tipulit Io Horim Mitalelim [“To Protect the House”: Theory and Practice of Forming a Therapeutic Alliance With Abusive Parents]" Chavrat VeRevacha (2010)

[3]

Bowlby J. (1973)

[4]

Bowlby J. (1980)

[5]

Bowlby J. (1982)

[6]

Using thematic analysis in psychology

Virginia Braun, Victoria Clarke

Qualitative Research in Psychology 10.1191/1478088706qp063oa

[7]

Child Welfare Information Gatewayn.d. Homepage.https://www.childwelfare.gov.

[8]

Cohen B.‐T. (2005)

[9]

10.1111/j.1365‐2206.2009.00662.x

[10]

Denzin N. K. (2011)

[11]

Dolev T. R.Sabo‐Lael &D.Ben‐Rabi2008.Youth Law Social Workers in Israel: Roles and Responsibilities. [In Hebrew].

[12]

10.1037/ort0000185

[13]

Gratzke M. "Love Is What People Say It Is: Performativity and Narrativity in Critical Love Studies" Journal of Popular Romance Studies (2017)

[14]

Grinell R. M. (2005)

[15]

10.1007/s10643‐019‐00951‐7

[16]

Israel's Ministry of Social Affairs. n.d.https://www.molsa.gov.il.

[17]

10.1016/j.childyouth.2020.105223

[18]

Kromer‐Nevo M. "Avodah Socialit Mudat‐Oni: Paradigma Chadash Lepractika im Mishpachot Beoni [Poverty‐Conscious Social Work: A New Paradigm for Practice With Families in Poverty]" Chavrat VeRevacha (2015)

[19]

Lampert A. (1997)

[20]

Lampert A. (2007)

[21]

Lincoln Y. S.&E. G.Guba1985.Naturalistic Inquiry.Sage Publications.

[22]

10.1177/0743558409357235

[23]

Peretz Y. (2008)

[24]

Peterson C. (2004)

[25]

10.1007/978-3-030-44278-1

[26]

10.1016/j.childyouth.2010.01.007

[27]

Sinai‐Glazer H. "Tfishat Haemahot Shel Ovdot Socialiot Collaniot (Ovdot Mishpacha) Bemachlakot Leshirutim Chavratiim [the Perception of Mothers of Inclusive Social Workers (Family Workers) in Social Services Departments]" Social Security (2018)

[28]

Smith J. (2003)

[29]

Solomon R. C. (1991)

[30]

Stangor C. (2014)

[31]

10.1023/b:casw.0000035224.93771.b1

[32]

Weiss M. (1991)

[33]

Winnicott D. W. (1992)

[34]

Zabar Ben‐Yahoshua N. (2001)

Metrics

0

Citations

34

References

Details

Published: Jul 28, 2025
Vol/Issue: 31(2)
Pages: 988-998
License: View

Authors

A

Ayelet Guy Menashe

The Paul Baerwald School of Social Work and Social Welfare The Hebrew University of Jerusalem Jerusalem Israel

B

Bella Klebanov

The Paul Baerwald School of Social Work and Social Welfare The Hebrew University of Jerusalem Jerusalem Israel

C

Carmit Katz

The Paul Baerwald School of Social Work and Social Welfare The Hebrew University of Jerusalem Jerusalem Israel

Cite This Article

Ayelet Guy Menashe, Bella Klebanov, Carmit Katz (2025). Can Parental Love and Harm Coexist? The Perceptions of Child Protective Social Workers in Israel. Child & Family Social Work, 31(2), 988-998. https://doi.org/10.1111/cfs.70023

Can Parental Love and Harm Coexist? The Perceptions of Child Protective Social Workers in Israel

You May Also Like