journal article
Mar 31, 2026
Sartre and the Dialectic of Freedom †
Abstract
Abstract
In
Being and Nothingness
, Sartre claims that consciousness is absolutely and inevitably free. This article defends his ontological conception of freedom against the charge that it cannot account for our experience of limitation, coercion, and external causal determination. I argue that Sartre's claim should not be understood as asserting the imperviousness of consciousness to external limitations or causes but rather its irreducibility to them. Because its activity cannot be exhaustively explained by appealing to them alone, consciousness always contributes to the constitution of its own experience as a free act of self‐determination. After examining Sartre's critiques of determinism and indeterminism, I argue that ontological freedom can be understood in terms of a dialectic between external determination and self‐determination, such that consciousness realizes its freedom in and through conditions limiting its free activity.
In
Being and Nothingness
, Sartre claims that consciousness is absolutely and inevitably free. This article defends his ontological conception of freedom against the charge that it cannot account for our experience of limitation, coercion, and external causal determination. I argue that Sartre's claim should not be understood as asserting the imperviousness of consciousness to external limitations or causes but rather its irreducibility to them. Because its activity cannot be exhaustively explained by appealing to them alone, consciousness always contributes to the constitution of its own experience as a free act of self‐determination. After examining Sartre's critiques of determinism and indeterminism, I argue that ontological freedom can be understood in terms of a dialectic between external determination and self‐determination, such that consciousness realizes its freedom in and through conditions limiting its free activity.
Topics
No keywords indexed for this article. Browse by subject →
References
37
[1]
Baiasu S. "Existentialist Freedom, Distorted Normativity, and Emancipation" Oñati Socio‐legal Series (2015)
[2]
Baldwin T. "The Original Choice in Sartre and Kant" Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society (1979) 10.1093/aristotelian/80.1.31
[3]
Detmer D. (1988)
[4]
Engels K. S. "Schopenhauer's Intelligible Character and Sartre's Fundamental Project" Idealistic Studies (2014) 10.5840/idstudies201521021
[5]
Fell J. P. "Sartre's Theory of Motivation: Some Clarifications" Journal of the British Society for Phenomenology (1970) 10.1080/00071773.1970.11006123
[6]
Føllesdal D. (1981)
[7]
Frankfurt H. "Freedom of the Will and the Concepts of a Person" The Journal of Philosophy (1983) 10.2307/2024717
[8]
Gardner S. (2009)
[9]
Grelland H. H. "The Case for Sartrean Freedom" Sartre Studies International (2006) 10.3167/135715506780646240
[10]
Grüne S. "Sartre on Mistaken Sincerity" European Journal of Philosophy (2003) 10.1111/1468-0378.00180
[11]
Hatzimoysis A. (2017)
[12]
Jones G. E. "Sartre, Consciousness, and Responsibility" Philosophy and Phenomenological Research (1980) 10.2307/2107407
[13]
Jones P. "Sartre's Concept of Freedom" Sartre Studies International (2015)
[14]
Kane R. (2005)
[15]
Landau I. "Foundationless Freedom and Meaninglessness of Life in Sartre's Being and Nothingness" Sartre Studies International (2012) 10.3167/ssi.2012.180101
[16]
Landau I. "Sartre's Absolute Freedom in Being and Nothingness: The Problems Persist" Philosophy Today (2012) 10.5840/philtoday20125648
[17]
Liu R. "Three interpretations of freedom in Sartre's Being and Nothingness" The Humanistic Psychologist (2022) 10.1037/hum0000226
[18]
Olson R. G. "The Three Theories of Motivation in the Philosophy of Jean‐Paul Sartre" Ethics (1956) 10.1086/291055
[19]
O'Shiel D. "Drives as Original Facticity" Sartre Studies International (2013) 10.3167/ssi.2013.190101
[20]
Pleydell‐Peirce A. G. "Freedom, Emotion and Choice in the Philosophy of Jean‐Paul Sartre" Journal of the British Society for Phenomenology (1970) 10.1080/00071773.1970.11006124
[21]
Poellner P. "Early Sartre on Freedom and Ethics" European Journal of Philosophy (2015) 10.1111/j.1468-0378.2012.00532.x
[22]
Rae G. "Sartre on Action: Decentring the Will" Journal of the British Society for Phenomenology (2024) 10.1080/00071773.2024.2332200
[23]
Rosenberg J. F. "Apperception and Sartre's ‘Pre‐Reflective Cogito.’" American Philosophical Quarterly (1981)
[24]
Sartre J.P. "Lettre de Jean‐Paul Sartre à Gabriel Marcel" Revue de la BNF (2014)
[25]
Sartre J.P. (2007)
[26]
Sartre J.P. (2002)
[27]
Sartre J.P. "Itinerary of a Thought" New Left Review (1969) 10.64590/g61
[28]
Sartre J.P. (1992)
[29]
Sartre J.P. (1962)
[30]
Sartre J.P. (1960)
[31]
Trotter G. A. "Unconscious Structure in Sartre and Lacan" Psychoanalytische Perspectieven (2018)
[32]
Vanello D. "Sartre's Theory of Motivation" The Southern Journal of Philosophy (2019) 10.1111/sjp.12321
[33]
Wang S. "Reason and the limits of existential freedom: Why Sartre is not a voluntarist" Philosophy Today (2006) 10.5840/philtoday200650344
[34]
Webber J. "Sartre's Critique of Husserl" British Journal for the History of Philosophy (2020) 10.1080/09608788.2019.1591339
[35]
Webber J. "Sartre's Theory of Character" European Journal of Philosophy (2006) 10.1111/j.1468-0378.2006.00245.x
[36]
Williford K. (2011)
[37]
Wolf S. (1990) 10.1093/oso/9780195056167.001.0001
Metrics
0
Citations
37
References
Details
- Published
- Mar 31, 2026
- License
- View
Cite This Article
James Sares (2026). Sartre and the Dialectic of Freedom
†. European Journal of Philosophy. https://doi.org/10.1111/ejop.70085
Related
You May Also Like
Kant on the Laws of Nature: Laws, Necessitation, and the Limitation of Our Knowledge
James Kreines · 2009
23 citations