journal article
Open Access
Sep 12, 2024
Responsibility Gaps and Technology: Old Wine in New Bottles?
Abstract
ABSTRACTRecent work in philosophy of technology has come to bear on the question of responsibility gaps. Some authors argue that the increase in the autonomous capabilities of decision‐making systems makes it impossible to properly attribute responsibility for AI‐based outcomes. In this article we argue that one important, and often neglected, feature of recent debates on responsibility gaps is how this debate maps on to old debates in responsibility theory. More specifically, we suggest that one of the key questions that is still at issue is the significance of the reactive attitudes, and how these ought to feature in our theorizing about responsibility. We will therefore provide a new descriptive categorization of different perspectives with respect to responsibility gaps. Such reflection can provide analytical clarity about what is at stake between the various interlocutors in this debate. The main upshot of our account is the articulation of a way to frame this ‘new’ debate by drawing on the rich intellectual history of ‘old’ concepts. By regarding the question of responsibility gaps as being concerned with questions of metaphysical priority, we see that the problem of these gaps lies not in any advanced technology, but rather in how we think about responsibility.
Topics
No keywords indexed for this article. Browse by subject →
References
57
[1]
Arpaly N. (2006)
[7]
D'Arms J. (2006)
[10]
[16]
Kahn P. T.Kanda H.Ishiguro B. T.Gill J.Ruckert S.Shen H. E.Gary A. L.Reichert N. G.Freier andR. L.Severson.Do People Hold a Humanoid Robot Morally Accountable for the Harm It Causes?Paper presented at the Seventh Annual ACM/IEEE International Conference on Human–Robot Interaction (HRI'12) Boston March 5–8 2012.
10.1145/2157689.2157696
[18]
[19]
[25]
Lauwaert L.
[28]
[29]
Malle B. (2015)
[30]
Malle B. M.Scheutz J.Forlizzi andJ.Voiklis.Which Robot Am I Thinking About? The Impact of Action and Appearance on People's Evaluations of a Moral RobotPaper presented at the Eleventh Annual Meeting of the IEEE Conference on Human–Robot Interaction (HRI'16) Christchurch New York 2016.
10.1109/hri.2016.7451743
[35]
Pereboom D. (2003)
[37]
[39]
[41]
[42]
[45]
Strawson P. F. "Freedom and Resentment" Proceedings of the British Academy (1962)
[46]
[47]
[48]
Showing 50 of 57 references
Metrics
9
Citations
57
References
Details
- Published
- Sep 12, 2024
- Vol/Issue
- 42(1)
- Pages
- 337-356
- License
- View
Authors
Cite This Article
Ann‐Katrien Oimann, Fabio Tollon (2024). Responsibility Gaps and Technology: Old Wine in New Bottles?. Journal of Applied Philosophy, 42(1), 337-356. https://doi.org/10.1111/japp.12763
Related
You May Also Like
Professional Discretion and Accountability in the Welfare State
Anders Molander, Harald Grimen · 2012
122 citations
Rape Myths and Domestic Abuse Myths as Hermeneutical Injustices
Katharine Jenkins · 2016
89 citations