journal article
Open Access
Jan 01, 2023
Between Dogma and Data: Wilhelm Schmidt and the Afterlives of 19th-Century Ethnolinguistics
Abstract
Father Wilhelm Schmidt SVD (1868-1954) was one of the great linguistic and ethnological information hoarders of the early 20th century. Through the missionary Society of the Divine Word, he coordinated an army of trained fieldworkers who supplied him with information for his twelve-volume synthesis of world religions, his atlas of the world’s languages, and the journal Anthropos. Schmidt saw himself as practicing Catholic modern science, based on historical criticism and observational data. His guiding tenet was that language structures and material culture were linked to intersecting patterns of original Kulturkreise (cultural spheres), each with their own form of primeval monotheistic religious awareness. In other words, Schmidt sought to confirm Catholic dogma through data; a confirmation bias that mainly taints his ethnological work. This article investigates to what extent it also informed his more technical linguistic work, and how the two are interrelated.
Topics
No keywords indexed for this article. Browse by subject →
References
85
[1]
Bachofen, Johann Jakob. 1861. Das Mutterrecht. Eine Untersuchung über die Gynaikokratie der alten Welt nach ihren religiösen und rechtlichen Natur. Stuttgart: Krais & Hoffmann.
[2]
[3]
Bornemann, Fritz. 1954. Verzeichnis der Schriften von P. (W. Schmidt Schmidt S.V.D. (1868-1954). Anthropos 49(3-4) : 385-432.
[4]
Bornemann, Fritz 1980. P.W. Schmidt und Kardinal Innitzer. Zwölf Aufsätze, ed. by Fritz Bornemann. Rome: Collegium Verbi Divini (Analecta SVD, 53). 99-136.
[5]
Bornemann, Fritz 1982. P. Wilhelm Schmidt Schmidt S.V.D. 1868-1954. Rome: Collegium Verbi Divini (Analecta SVD, 59).
[6]
Brandewie, Ernst. 1990. When Giants Walked the Earth. The Life and Times of Wilhelm Schmidt SVD, vol. 4. : Fribourg: Universitätsverlag (Studia Instituti Anthropos, 44).
[7]
Burgmann, Arnold. 1954. P.W. Schmidt als Linguist. Anthropos (49(3-4): 627-658.
[8]
Burgmann, Arnold 1961. Professor Dr. Wilhelm Koppers SVD †. Anthropos (56(5-6): 721-736.
[9]
Courtois, Luc. 2004. La première Semaine d'ethnologie religieuse de Louvain en 1912 : les débuts difficiles d'une démarche progressiste sur fond de crise moderniste. Anthropologie et missiologie, XIXe-XXe siècles. Entre connivence et rivalité, ed. by Olivier Servais & Gérard Van't Spijker. Paris: Karthala. 95-118.
[10]
Curr, Edward Micklethwaite. 1887. The Australian Race , ed. by John Ferres .4 vols. & Melbourne & London: Trübner & co.
[12]
Cust, Robert Needham.1883. A Sketch of the Modern Languages of Africa. 2 vols. : London: Trübner & co.
[13]
[14]
Darnell, Regna. 2001. Invisible Genealogies: A History of Americanist Anthropology. Lincoln & London : University of Nebraska Press.
10.5250/9781496245274
[15]
Drexel, Albert. 1921-1925. Gliederung der Afrikanischen Sprachen. Eine systematische Untersuchung mit Berücksichtigung des völkergeschichtlichen Problems. Anthropos 16-17(1-): 72-20; 18-20-19(1-): 12-20; 20(1-2): 210-243; 20(3-4): 444-460.
[16]
Drexel, Albert. 1928. Kann das Ful als hamitische Sprache gelten? 76 Sprachwissenschaftliche, ethnologische, religionswissenschaftliche, prähistorische und andere Studien. Festschrift für Pater , Wilhelm Schmidt, ed. by Wilhem Koppers. Vienna: Mechitharisten-Verlag. 46-60.
[17]
Drexel, Albert. 1934. Atlas . linguisticus. 2 vols. Innsbruck : Kartographisches Institut.
[18]
Durkheim, Émile. 1912. Les Formes élémentaires de la Vie religieuse. Paris : Presses universitaires de France.
[19]
Frazer, James. 1890. The Golden Bough: A Study in Comparative Religion. 2 vols. London: MacMillan.
[20]
Frazer, James. 1906-1915. The Golden Bough: A Study in Magic and Religion. 3rd ed., 12 vols. London: MacMillan.
[21]
Frazer, James. 1910. Totemism and Exogamy: A Treatise on Certain Early Forms of Superstition and Society. 4 vols. : London: MacMillan.
[22]
Frobenius, Leo. 1898. Der Ursprung der afrikanischen Kulturen. Berlin: Borntraeger.
[23]
Frobenius, Leo. 1900. Die Kulturformen Ozeaniens. Petermanns Geographische Mitteilungen : 46: 204-271.
[24]
Gingrich, Andre. 2005. The German-Speaking Countries. Ruptures, Schools, and Nontraditions: Reassessing the History of Sociocultural Anthropology in Germany. One Discipline, Four Ways: British, German, French, and American Anthropology, ed. by Fredrik Barth, Andre Gingrich, Robert Parkin & Sydel Silverman. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. 61-153.
[25]
Graebner, Fritz. 1905. Kulturkreise und Kulturschichten in Ozeanien. Zeitschrift für Ethnologie : 37: 58-84.
[26]
Graebner, Fritz. 1906. Wanderung und Entwicklung sozialer Systeme in Australien. Globus 90(12): 181-14; 90(13): 207-14; 90(14): 220-15; 90(15): 237-241.
[27]
Graebner, Fritz. 1911. Methode der Ethnologie. Heidelberg: Winter.
[29]
Hale, Kenneth. 1966. Appendix to XXIX: The Paman Group of the Pama-Nyungan Phylic Family. [Thematic issue] Languages of the World: Indo-Pacific Fascicle Six, by Geoffrey N. O'Grady, C.F. Voegelin and F.M. Voegelin. Anthropological Linguistics (8(2): 162-197.
[30]
International Institute of African Languages and Cultures. 1927. Practical Orthography of African Languages. Le Maître phonetique (5(42): 1-16.
[32]
Koppers, Wilhelm. 1949. Der Urmensch und sein Weltbild. Vienna: Herold.
[33]
Koppers, Wilhelm. 1959. Grundsätzliches und Geschichtliches zur ethnologischen Kulturkreislehre. Beiträge Österreichs zur Erforschung der Vergangenheit und Kulturgeschichte der Menschheit mit besonderer Berücksichtigung Mitteleuropas, ed. by Emil Breitinger. Horn: Berger. 110-126.
[35]
Lepsius, Richard. 1855. Standard Alphabet for Reducing Unwritten Languages and Foreign Graphic Systems to a Uniform Orthography in European Letters. London: Seeley.
[36]
Lepsius, Richard. 1880. Nubische Grammatik, mit einer Einleitung über die Völker und Sprachen Afrikas. Berlin: Hertz.
[37]
Le Roy, Alexandre. 1905. Les Pygmées. Négrilles d'Afrique et négritos de l'Asie. Tours : Mame.
[38]
Le Roy, Alexandre. 1909. La religion des primitifs. Paris : Beauchesne.
[39]
Maas, Utz. 2018. Schmidt, Pater Wilhelm. Verfolgung und Auswanderung deutschsprachiger Sprachforscher 1933-1945, ed. by Utz Maas. [https://zflprojekte.de/sprachforscher-im-exil/index.php/katalog-m-z/s/415-schmidt-pater-wilhelm, accessed on 27/09/2022].
[40]
Marchand, Suzanne. 2003. Priests among the Pygmies: Wilhelm Schmidt and the Counter-Reformation in Austrian Ethnology. Worldly Provincialism: German Anthropology in the Age of Empire, ed. by H. Glenn Penny & Matti Bunzl. Ann Arbor : University of Michigan Press. 283-316.
[41]
Mary, André. 2010. La preuve de Dieu par les Pygmées : Le laboratoire équatorial d'une ethnologie catholique. Cahiers d'études africaines : 198-199199-200 : 881-905.
10.4000/etudesafricaines.16411
[42]
Mary, André. 2015. Science de l'Homme ou ‘Science de Dieu' ? Révélation primitive et formes élémentaires du religieux. 1913. La recomposition de la science de l'Homme, ed. by Christine Laurière. Paris : Bérose - Encyclopédie internationale des histoires de l'anthropologie (Les Carnets de Bérose, 7). 196-222.
[43]
Mauss, Marcel. 1913. P. Wilhelm Schmidt, Die Stellung der Pygmäenvölker in der Entwicklungsgeschichte des Menschen [review]. L'Année sociologique 12 : 65-69.
[44]
Mauss, Marcel. 1930. Les Civilisations : éléments et formes. La Civilisation. Le mot et l'idée, ed. by Lucien Febvre, Ernest Tonnelat, Marcel Mauss, Alfredo Niceforo & Louis Weber. Paris : La Renaissance du Livre. 81-106.
[45]
Meillet, Antoine & Marcel Cohen, eds. 1924. Les langues du monde. Paris : Champion.
[46]
Meinhof, Carl. 1928. Principles of Practical Orthography for African Languages – I. Africa: Journal of the International African Institute (1(2): 228-239.
10.2307/1155939
[47]
Mischek, Udo. 2008. Antisemitismus und Antijudaismus in den Werken und Arbeiten Pater (Wilhelm Schmidts Schmidts S.V.D. (1868-1954). The Study of Religion under the Impact of Fascism, ed. by Horst Junginger. Leiden : Brill (Studies in the History of Religion, 117). 467-488.
10.1163/ej.9789004163263.i-663.99
[48]
Müller, Friedrich. 1876-1888. Grundriß der Sprachwissenschaft. 4 vols. Vienna: Hölder.
[49]
Powell, John Wesley. 1891. Indian Linguistic Families of America North of Mexico. Seventh Annual Report of the Bureau of Ethnology to the Secretary of the Smithsonian Institution, 1885-'86. Washington: Govt. Printing Office. 1-142.
[50]
Rebay-Salisbury, Katharina. 2011. Thoughts in Circles: Kulturkreislehre as a Hidden Paradigm in Past and Present Archaeological Interpretations. Investigating Archaeological Cultures: Material Culture, Variability, and Transmission, ed. by Benjamin Roberts & Marc Vander Linden. New York : Springer. 41-59.
10.1007/978-1-4419-6970-5_3
Showing 50 of 85 references
Metrics
1
Citations
85
References
Details
- Published
- Jan 01, 2023
- Vol/Issue
- 44-2
- Pages
- 57-77
- License
- View
Authors
Cite This Article
Floris Solleveld (2023). Between Dogma and Data: Wilhelm Schmidt and the Afterlives of 19th-Century Ethnolinguistics. Histoire Épistémologie Langage, 44-2, 57-77. https://doi.org/10.4000/hel.3029
Related
You May Also Like
Les derniers locuteurs : au croisement des typologies des locuteurs de langues en danger
Jhonnatan Rangel · 2017
1 citations
Phénoménologies et théories du langage autour de Merleau-Ponty
Simone Aurora, Marina De Palo · 2023