“Sacrifice Zones” in the Green Energy Economy: Toward an Environmental Justice Framework

Dayna Nadine Scott; Adrian A. Smith

doi:10.7202/1042776ar

journal article Jan 05, 2018

“Sacrifice Zones” in the Green Energy Economy: Toward an Environmental Justice Framework

Dayna Nadine Scott Adrian A. Smith

McGill Law Journal Vol. 62 No. 3 pp. 861-898 · McGill University Library and Archives

View at Publisher Save 10.7202/1042776ar

Abstract

The environmental justice movement validates the grassroots struggles of residents of places which Steve Lerner refers to as “sacrifice zones”: low-income and racialized communities shouldering more than their fair share of environmental harms related to pollution, contamination, toxic waste, and heavy industry. On this account, disparities in wealth and power, often inscribed and re-inscribed through social processes of racialization, are understood to produce disparities in environmental burdens. Here, we attempt to understand how these dynamics are shifting in the green energy economy under settler colonial capitalism. We consider the possibility that the political economy of green energy contains its own sacrifice zones. Drawing on preliminary empirical research undertaken in southwestern Ontario in 2015, we document local resistance to renewable energy projects. Residents mounted campaigns against wind turbines based on suspected health effects and against solar farms based on arable land and food justice concerns, and in both cases, grounded their resistance in a generalized claim, which might be termed a “right to landscape”. We conclude that this resistance, contrary to typical framings which dismiss it as NIMBYism, has resonances with broader claims about environmental justice and may signal larger structural shifts worth devoting scholarly attention to. In the end, however, we do not wholly accept the sacrifice zone characterization of this resistance either, as our analysis reveals it to be far more complex and ambiguous than such a framing allows. But we maintain that taking this resistance seriously, rather than treating it as merely obstructionist to a transition away from fossil capitalism, reveals a counter-hegemonic potential at its core. There are seeds in this resistance with the power to push back on the deepening of capitalist relations that would otherwise be ushered in by an uncritical embrace of “green energy” enthusiasm.

Topics

No keywords indexed for this article. Browse by subject →

Cited By

77

Green colonialism or green transformation? The equity implications of clean hydrogen trade

Marie Dejonghe, Thijs Van de Graaf · 2025

Political Geography

Reacting to the Rural Burden: Understanding Opposition to Utility‐Scale Solar Development in Upstate New York☆

Roberta S. Nilson, Richard C. Stedman · 2023

Rural Sociology

What is ‘local’ about Smart Local Energy Systems? Emerging stakeholder geographies of decentralised energy in the United Kingdom

Chad Walker, Patrick Devine-Wright · 2021

Energy Research & Social Scienc...

The spatial politics of energy conflicts: How competing constructions of scale shape pipeline and shale gas struggles in Canada

Carol Hunsberger, Rasmus Kløcker Larsen · 2021

Energy Research & Social Scienc...

Volatile Photovoltaics: Green Industrialization, Sacrifice Zones, and the Political Ecology of Solar Energy in Germany

Andrea Brock, Benjamin K. Sovacool · 2021

Annals of the American Association...

Green Sacrifice Zones, or Why a Green New Deal Cannot Ignore the Cost Shifts of Just Transitions

Christos Zografos, Paul Robbins · 2020

One Earth

Metrics

77

Citations

0

References

Details

Published: Jan 05, 2018
Vol/Issue: 62(3)
Pages: 861-898

Authors

Cite This Article

Dayna Nadine Scott, Adrian A. Smith (2018). “Sacrifice Zones” in the Green Energy Economy: Toward an Environmental Justice Framework. McGill Law Journal, 62(3), 861-898. https://doi.org/10.7202/1042776ar

“Sacrifice Zones” in the Green Energy Economy: Toward an Environmental Justice Framework

You May Also Like